Vintage Boxing Hall of Fame error Plaque measures 12 1/2 x 8 1/2, the story on this is The original boxing Hall of Fame was founded by Nat Fleischer and the plaques of the inductees hung first at Madison Square Garden and later the Rink magazine offices in New York, Jake Kilrain had been elected in 1965. The plaque was mistakenly produced with a photo of Johnny Kilbane, a 1960 inductee. They were hung in alphabetical order, with Kilbane and Kilrain next to each other, yet it was 10 years before the error was corrected.