Tony Putty Artifacts, IN - Read over 381 Reviews from Customers
LiveAuctioneers Logo

Bidder Reviews for Tony Putty Artifacts (381)

badge TOP RATED
4.7 out of 5.0 Stars
trophy
Accurate Descriptions
trophy
Quick Responses
trophy
Easy Payments
trophy
Seamless Shipping

1-50 of 381 Reviews

All Ratings
Highest Rated

Henry
East Falmouth, MA

Apr 09, 2024
was reliable
Seems reliable on the basis of my first transaction. Look forward to their next auction.
Report
6 7/16" Highly Polished Jade Celt. Mayan/Olmec

Frank
San Francisco, CA

Mar 31, 2024
4 1/2" Tall Silver Plated Pendant. Ex Tom Browner and Jake Vahle.

Robin
Coldwater, OH

Mar 30, 2024
3 1/2" Thebes. Made of well patinated Hornstone. Kentucky

Doug
Huntington, IN

Mar 30, 2024
3 3/4" Adena. Madison Co, IN. Ex Larry Swann

Robin
Coldwater, OH

Nov 20, 2023
shipping time
great
Report
5 7/8" Dickson.  St. Charles Co, MO.  Large and very thin (.28" max).  Ex-Dean Mesnard.  Granger COA

Gerry
Niantic, CT

Nov 20, 2023
Items received promptly and as described.
Great transaction
Report
5 1/4" Hornstone Cache Blade.  Hardin Co, KY.  Hornstone vivid Bullseye.  Ex-Dale Rector

Lane
Lincoln, NE

Nov 19, 2023
Very nice 4 1/16" Adena Flintridge Blade.  Fairfield Co, OH.  Ex-Dale Rector.  COAs

Steven
Indianapolis, IN

Nov 18, 2023
Years and years of direct dealings without issue
I’ve been dealing with Putty auctions for well over twenty years and it’s been a very positive experience, on both the buying end and selling end Very honest, knowledgeable and pleasant and easy to work with, a lot of artifact auctions come and go, I believe this one is here to stay, thanks for all the good years!!
Report
4 3/4" Dovetail.  Illinois.  Glossy, tinted Burligton.  Pictured in WW#9.  Putty G10 and Rogers COAs

Richard
Harbor Springs, MI

Sep 07, 2023

David
Rockford, IL

Sep 03, 2023

Vicki
Franklin, IN

Sep 02, 2023
I have said it before but honesty is so Tony.
Tony cares about his followers. He makes the auctions different, never boring. My son and I get on our phones, grab carefully the sale book and talk about the items for hours. In the end we usually get that special item we had hoped for.
Report

Emily
Chicago, IL

Sep 02, 2023

William
West Tisbury, MA

Sep 02, 2023

Robin
Coldwater, OH

Sep 02, 2023
Quality Relics. Fast shipping
One of the best at giving accurate descriptions and has excellent packaging
Report

James
Lake Saint Louis, MO

Sep 02, 2023

Myles
Land O Lakes, FL

Aug 25, 2023
The best points and relics in the business!
Great material, accurately described, and easy to work with. I always lokk forward to their auctions!
Report

Mike
Sylvester, GA

Jun 04, 2023
9 1/8" D.  Painted Bowl.  Chupicuaro culture (600 BC to 400 AD.   Dr. Earl Riddick

Michael
Fowler, IN

Jun 03, 2023
9 1/2" Porphyry Delta Celt with Flared Bit.  Yazoo Co, MS.  Large, finely made

Robert
Cottage Grove, WI

Jun 03, 2023
Colorful 4 3/4" Dickson.  Clinton Co, IL.  Red, white and blue beauty.  Ex-Jan Sorgenfrei

Greg
Shelbyville, IN

Jun 03, 2023
Great Transaction!
Everything went well! No problems!
Report
4 1/4" Dovetail.  Wells Co, IN.  White Coshocton with blue/gray spotting.  COA

Scott
Danville, KY

Jun 03, 2023
11 1/8" Ft. Ancient Cameo Bowl.  Ross Co, OH.  Davis COA.  A large Ohio ceramic.

Anthony
Little Rock, AR

Jun 03, 2023
4 1/2" Coiled Snake Pipe.  TN.  Engraved.  Mississippian to Early Historic Ceramic Pipe.

William
West Tisbury, MA

Jun 03, 2023
2 11/16" Shield Bannerstone.  Farmington Meadows, CT.  Highly polished.

Toney
West Plains, MO

Jun 03, 2023
4 1/8" Sandstone Kneeling Human Effigy Pipe.  Osage Co, MO.  Very good condition.

Josh
New York, NY

Jun 03, 2023
Book:  Art of the Ancient Caddo (Bonds).  Hardbound.  Excellent condition.

David
Laramie, WY

Mar 25, 2023
Smooth Transaction
As always, smooth transaction and prompt shipping
Report

Daniel
Jefferson City, MO

Mar 25, 2023

James
Omaha, NE

Mar 22, 2023
In house shipping
In house shipping a plus and reasonable shipping rates
Report

Michael
Saint Clairsville, OH

Mar 19, 2023

Nicky
Monticello, AR

Mar 12, 2023
He is great about answering the phone.
It’s great to be assured that you will have the opportunity to verbally speak with him without a wait or hassle. In my book that is superb. Thank you Tony. Respectfully, Nicky A. IV
Report
3" Hematite Plummet.  Stoddard Co, MO.  Ungrooved.

Dennis
Kutztown, PA

Mar 07, 2023
Great Auction for True Pieces of History!
Never a Problem with Tony Putty! A # 1, and Thanks for That 👍 🥂
Report
Book:  Ancient Art of Ohio by Lar Hothem.  Hardbound, hundreds of artifact photos.  Very fine

William
West Tisbury, MA

Jan 01, 2023
9 3/4" Taino Monolithic Axe.  Hispaniola (Dominican Republic).  Rare form in any  culture.  Highly

Cliff
Lake Forest, IL

Dec 31, 2022
Top quality and service
Accurately described, excellent quality, and communication top-notch. Wonderful auction house!
Report
6 1/2" Copper Celt.  Provenance unknown.  Deaccessioned from a private museum in PA.  Very fine

R. Garland
Bloomington, IL

Dec 31, 2022
2 5/16" Quad.  Kentucky.  Motley COA.  Wonderful little Quad

Brian
Homer Glen, IL

Dec 31, 2022
Opportunity
I have great appreciation for T & T serving as a platform for great collections returning back to the collecting community.
Report
3 5/8" Quartz Butterfly Bannerstone.  Brown Co, IL.  Well made.  A nicely and evenly weathered

Thomas
Naples, FL

Dec 31, 2022
Bid with confidence. Tom in Naples
Great person and auction house.
Report
5 1/8"Two Headed Birdstone.  Slate with tally marks on back and heads.  Believed to be modern.  Old

Stanley
Eddyville, IL

Nov 05, 2022
Great experience! Fast shipping!
Great!
Report
10 1/4" Flint Spade.  IL.  Very well made with excellent bit polish

John
Liberty, NC

Nov 05, 2022
Great artifacts and service
Great selection of artifacts and efficient service.
Report
1 7/8" Knife River Flint Allen.  MO.  Thin and translucent.  Ex-Hunt

Jim
Norman, OK

Nov 05, 2022
Very accurate offering of artifacts from Spiro!
Everything here was exactly as described and provenance correct!
Report
15 Pages written by Willis Tilton on his letterhead stationary

Ken
Gastonia, NC

Aug 27, 2022
Very easy to deal with.
Everything was done online except the credit card no.
Report
Books:  All four Volumes of  Greg Perino and Robert Bell's Guides

Robert
Boise, ID

Aug 27, 2022
4 1/8" 3/4 Groove Axe.  Potlatch, Idaho.   Rare Idaho Axe.  Ex-Comer

James
Miami Beach, FL

Aug 14, 2022
The Best of the Best
Tony Putty is always a clas act with amazing artifacts and excellent catalogs. Beautifully illustrated and researched. I always look forward to the next auction. Thanks Tony
Report
4 3/4" Graham Cave.  Boone Co, MO.  Attractive coloring.  Thin

John
Matthews, NC

Jul 16, 2022
Good auction house
Purchased several things over the years and very pleased. Good response w/questions too.
Report

Bennett
Blairstown, NJ

May 30, 2022

Ray
Sedalia, MO

May 22, 2022

Quinton
Kansas City, MO

May 22, 2022

David
Tours, FR

May 21, 2022
Perfect
Perfect
Report

Craig
Merrill, IA

May 21, 2022

Lonnie
Eufaula, OK

Mar 05, 2022
TONY IS VERY HONEST. EASY TO DEAL WITH AND HELPFUL
I HAVE BOUGHT RELICS MANY TIMES AND HAVE NEVER HAD A BAD RESULT
Report
3 7/8" Flintridge Hopewell with Rogers COA.  Ohio.

Bill
North Lewisburg, OH

Feb 26, 2022
Auction followthrough
Prompt responses to questions, receive purchased items quickly!
Report
5 3/8" Flared Bit Celt.  Illinois. Hardstone.  Ex-Dr.
View:
50
TOP